U.S. EDITIONTHEWEEKLYOBSERVER.COM

HOME  /  US  /  DENVER

US · DENVER

Judge Holds ICE in Contempt, Says Agency Made a 'Mockery' of Court by Rearresting a Freed Migrant

A Colorado federal judge found ICE in contempt after agents rearrested a man within minutes of his court-ordered release — part of a pattern immigration lawyers call 'sham releases.'

OS

BY OBSERVER STAFF

The Weekly Observer

NOV 20, 2026 · 4 MIN READ
fXinEMAIL
Judge Holds ICE in Contempt, Says Agency Made a 'Mockery' of Court by Rearresting a Freed Migrant
A judge's gavel. Illustrative photo, not from this case. (Katrin Bolovtsova/Pexels)

A federal judge in Colorado has held U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Trump administration in contempt after agents rearrested an immigrant moments after a court ordered him freed, the latest and most pointed rebuke yet in a monthslong standoff between the federal bench and ICE's Denver field office.

U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney's contempt order, reported this week by Colorado Politics, centers on Ramon Quintero Alvarez, a Mexican immigrant whose habeas corpus petition went unanswered by the U.S. Attorney's Office — triggering his automatic release under the law. Alvarez was let out of ICE custody on Oct. 27, according to a government court filing, only to be taken back into custody almost immediately.

'I received a direct order'

At a hearing, Nichole Black, ICE's assistant field office director in Denver, testified that she acted on explicit instructions from above. "I received a direct order," Black told the court, "to re-detain habeas releases that had some kind of criminality."

The ACLU of Colorado, which filed an amicus brief in the case, has accused ICE of running what it calls a pattern of "sham releases" — appearing to comply with judges' release orders while maintaining continuous custody of the people involved. The civil liberties group says ICE has since committed to ending the practice, a pledge Judge Sweeney noted in declining to impose further sanctions beyond the contempt finding itself.

"I RECEIVED A DIRECT ORDER TO RE-DETAIN HABEAS RELEASES THAT HAD SOME KIND OF CRIMINALITY"

Sweeney is not the only Colorado federal judge to confront the issue. In a separate case, a colleague ordered a different man released after an identical rearrest but stopped short of a contempt finding. And in May, Senior U.S. District Judge R. Brooke Jackson found that ICE had materially violated a standing injunction restricting warrantless arrests in Colorado — a sign, immigration attorneys say, of a broader breakdown between the agency and the courts overseeing it in the state.

What's next

Sweeney's order does not undo the underlying confrontation: ICE's Denver office remains under close judicial scrutiny, and the ACLU says it will keep monitoring whether the agency's pledge to stop the rearrests holds. No criminal or civil penalties beyond the contempt finding were announced.

SHARE THIS STORY