Girlfriend Arrested in Costa Rica Killing of California Surf Legend Kurt Van Dyke
Costa Rican investigators now say the death of surfer Kurt Van Dyke, known locally as "the King," was no home invasion — they've arrested his girlfriend and a second suspect on suspicion of helping carry out his killing.

Costa Rica's Judicial Investigation Agency (OIJ) has arrested the girlfriend of slain American surfer Kurt Van Dyke, months after initially describing his death as the result of a home invasion gone wrong.
Van Dyke, a well-known California surfer who'd become a fixture in Costa Rica's surf community — locals reportedly called him "the King" — was killed at his home in the country on February 14, 2026. Authorities identified the arrested woman only by her last name, Arroyo, 31, who they say was at the scene of the killing and escaped without serious injury. A second suspect, a 34-year-old man identified as Gutiérrez, was also detained in a raid on the Caribbean-coast town of Roxana, in Pococí canton, according to reporting from The Inertia.
Authorities say Arroyo is suspected of aiding whoever actually carried out the killing, rather than of delivering the fatal wounds herself. A preliminary OIJ release had listed asphyxiation and multiple stab wounds as Van Dyke's cause of death.
From home invasion to inside job
The case has shifted sharply since February, when investigators treated the killing as a burglary gone violent. Evidence gathered since then points to multiple suspects with a closer connection to Van Dyke than an opportunistic break-in would suggest, according to Fox LA's coverage of the arrests.
EVIDENCE NOW POINTS TO MULTIPLE SUSPECTS, NOT A SINGLE INTRUDER
Van Dyke's death was felt deeply in both the Southern California and Costa Rican surf communities, where friends and fellow surfers described him as a generous, larger-than-life presence who had made the Central American country his second home over decades of visits.
What's next
Costa Rican prosecutors have not yet filed formal charges against either Arroyo or Gutiérrez, and the OIJ says its investigation remains active. No court date has been set, and authorities have not ruled out further arrests as the case develops.