Senate Rejects Latest Bid to Rein In Trump's Iran War, 48-51, as GOP Support Shrinks to Three Votes
Tim Kaine called the midterm wipeout a 'historic repudiation' of the war, but Thursday's war-powers measure fell short for the second time since a rare bipartisan win in June.
The Senate on Thursday rejected the latest attempt to force President Trump to end hostilities with Iran, voting 48-51 against a House-passed resolution that would have directed the withdrawal of U.S. forces from the nine-month-old conflict, according to CBS News.
Nearly every Democrat backed the measure — only Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania voted no — and they were joined by just three Republicans: Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky. That's down from the four GOP defections that helped a similar resolution actually pass the Senate in June, the first war-powers vote to succeed after more than a dozen failed attempts since the war began in late February.
The measure, a concurrent resolution that would not have required Trump's signature, invoked the War Powers Resolution of 1973, which requires the withdrawal of U.S. forces from hostilities when Congress so directs by a vote of both chambers. The House passed its own version earlier this month; the Senate has not yet taken that one up.
"A Historic Repudiation"
Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., who has led most of the chamber's war-powers efforts, argued that this month's midterm results — in which Republicans suffered sweeping losses, with voters citing the war and its economic toll among their top concerns — should have moved more GOP senators off the fence. He called the results "a historic repudiation of the party holding onto the White House."
Instead, one Republican who voted for an earlier war-powers measure, Thom Tillis of North Carolina, flipped to no on Thursday. Tillis said the resolution "doesn't go to the president, so it's just a statement from Congress," while separately blasting Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth as "a failure" and saying he would pursue other avenues — such as funding fights — to hold the Pentagon accountable.
The White House maintains that the War Powers Resolution itself is unconstitutional and argues that a 60-day congressional clock on unauthorized hostilities was paused by an April ceasefire, even as both the U.S. and Iran have continued carrying out strikes since then. Trump has touted a framework agreement with Tehran to wind the conflict down, though its terms remain undisclosed; under the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act, any nuclear-related deal must be submitted to Congress before sanctions could be lifted, and Majority Leader John Thune has requested the text and an administration briefing.
Thursday's vote came against a backdrop of continued fighting: U.S. forces have struck Iranian positions on Qeshm Island in the Strait of Hormuz, Iran has hit back at Gulf states and shipping, and Bahrain says it intercepted an Iranian strike earlier this week. Democrats have now forced more than a dozen war-powers votes since February; only one, in June, has succeeded — and even that vote drew a furious response from Trump, who publicly criticized the Republicans who crossed over.
With the GOP's Senate majority narrowed after this month's midterms and the war showing no sign of a near-term resolution, Kaine and other Democrats say they intend to keep forcing votes — betting that public exhaustion with the conflict will eventually peel off more Republican support.