GOP Insiders Fear a 'Red Scream' Could Sink Their Senate Majority Next Week
With six days until Election Day, half a dozen senior Republican operatives tell Axios they can't see a path past 51 Senate seats — and some races once considered safe are suddenly close.
Republican strategists are bracing for a gut punch. Six days before the midterms, top GOP operatives privately say they can no longer see their party winning more than 51 Senate seats — barely enough to hold the chamber — according to an Axios report that dubbed the quiet panic a "red scream." Sen. Thom Tillis put it bluntly: "I think we'll have a net loss."
The warning signs are showing up race by race. In Maine, a Marist poll has Democrat Troy Jackson running two points ahead of Sen. Susan Collins among likely voters — within the margin of error — while The Hill reports election handicappers now call the race a toss-up. In Texas, Attorney General Ken Paxton is locked in an unexpectedly tight contest with Democratic state Rep. James Talarico, prompting both President Trump and Vice President Vance to campaign there this week.
"I THINK WE'LL HAVE A NET LOSS" — SEN. THOM TILLIS
Decision Desk HQ's model gives Democrats a 57% chance of flipping Senate control outright, with North Carolina seen as their best pickup opportunity and narrow leads emerging in Alaska, Maine, Texas and Ohio. Even traditionally safe red turf isn't immune: in Nebraska, independent Dan Osborn has polled ahead of Sen. Pete Ricketts, prompting Trump to fly in for a rally, even though most models still favor Ricketts to hold on.
Republican officials are now openly debating whether low enthusiasm among their own base — rather than a Democratic surge — is the bigger threat to the majority. The Senate has already left Washington for the campaign trail and isn't due back until the week of Nov. 9, meaning the fight for control will be decided entirely on the ground over the next six days.